# Why "May God have mercy on his soul!" is a dumb thing to say when an evil person dies. **URL:** \ **Category:** Philosophy & Theology\ **Created:** [October 28, 2026, 2:33pm UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171 "2026-10-28T14:33:03Z")\ **Posts on this page:** 9\ **Page:** 1
**Author:** ![Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/slinking_agony/32/842_2.png) [@Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/u/Slinking_Agony)\ **Post date:** [October 28, 2026, 2:33pm UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/1 "2026-10-28T14:33:03Z")
I keep seeing this thing where a judge will sentence an evil-doer to death and say “May God have mercy on your soul!” after doing so. Furthermore, in comment sections about evil people dying (Like an old rich jew having a stroke, for example) some people in the comment sections will say “May God have mercy on his soul!” There is no doubt in my mind that it is 99% Christians who say this phrase. I am not anti-Christian (Protestant Christian myself) but I am no cheerleader. Not a trained seal who claps his flappers on command. If I see my “Fellow Christians” say/do things that I have judged to be gay and retarded, I will point that out to them. 99.99999% of “Christians” are false for israel worship anyway, so I despise the majority, and the feeling is mutual. Now on to why I am no longer a fan of “May Gawd have marsey on his hole”. The Bible is very clear that after death, there are only two areas a soul can go to. There is dispute among Christians over whether a soul is judged instantly upon death, or if all will be judged on judgement day, which will be very far in the future. Either way, there are still only two areas that a soul can ultimately go to. Hell = for bad/faithless people Heaven = for good/faithful people There is also dispute on what exactly heaven and hell are like, but that is irrelevant to this discussion. Notice how there is NO “third place”. (CS Lewis believed in Purgatory and also that hell could be temporary, but for the purpose of this discussion, we will only recognize the two destinations above.) There is no “soft answer”. There is no “neutral, grey area” for someone to get sent to. Only Arcadia and Hades. In my mind, there can be no criminals in heaven. (Referring to serous criminals) There can be no browns in heaven. No jews. Especially not rich and powerful jews. Bad people existing in heaven defeats the whole point of it. How can an area be an eternal, peaceful, blissful pair-o-dice if there are niggers there? It cannot be. But there is no third afterlife. So, when a Christian says “May God have mercy on his soul”, what are they trying to say? That murderous chimps and circumsized kangs (Who both caused chaos and subversion while alive) should be spared? And thus allowed into heaven? Where they will continue their chaos and subversion? What the fuck does “mercy” mean if the afterlife in BINARY, as in ONLY TWO OPTIONS? Sigh. I do not understand my fellow Christians and I do not think I ever will. The only explanation I can think of is that it is sort of like an NPC in a video game. If an NPC is coded to spout retarded gay shit, they will spout retarded gay shit. The Christfaggotcuck heard “May gawd have Marsey on his hole” from somewhere, and so, the Christian repeats it mindlessly, not thinking of the ramifications of God having mercy on an evildoer, because there are only two areas a soul can be sent to. Anyway, what do you guys think? What does mercy mean if there are only two afterlives, and thus, sending evil people to heaven (the only option other than hell) will defeat the purpose of heaven, essentially punishing everyone there by forcing them to endure kikes and shitskins? ---
**Author:** ![Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/slinking_agony/32/842_2.png) [@Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/u/Slinking_Agony)\ **Post date:** [October 28, 2026, 2:53pm UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/2 "2026-10-28T14:53:08Z")
“May gawd have Marsey on his hole” Translation: “Yes, God should let kikes and niggers into heaven so they can continue torturing us for eternity, even after death, even in the ‘blissful’ pair-o-dice.” Christians are such gay retards. You can tell that they never put any thought into the ramifications of their own words. ---
**Author:** ![buddy\_vestigial](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/buddy_vestigial/32/871_2.png) [@buddy\_vestigial](https://briarfray.org/u/buddy_vestigial)\ **Post date:** [October 28, 2026, 6:41pm UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/3 "2026-10-28T18:41:31Z")
Aren’t you a furry? (If this is not supposed to be public forum knowledge pls Johnny delete this post or I will or whatever.) ---
**Author:** ![anonymous14](https://briarfray.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/a/896A67/32.png) [@anonymous14](https://briarfray.org/u/anonymous14)\ **Post date:** [October 28, 2026, 6:59pm UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/4 "2026-10-28T18:59:03Z")
Are you sure they’re not Catholic? > CS Lewis believed in Purgatory and also that hell could be temporary- Exactly this. This is the mentality behind it. > But for the purpose of this discussion, we will only recognize the two destinations above. But you’re right the ones who believe in a strict binary don’t really know what they’re saying. Though it is my belief that even the worst offenders don’t really know what they’re doing either. On paper they know what is wrong but don’t know why something is wrong. No matter how common sense or obvious it is something is wrong they still cannot fathom it. If questioned long enough they might eventually admit that not doing harm is more logical but they are unable to stop regardless. **“And the light shineth in darkness; and the darkness comprehended it not.” - John 1:5** Another angle to look at it is to question what even gives all these harmful actions so much weight in the first place? Most of it can be chalked up to being capable of dying, especially prematurely. It is the material body that creates the severity behind actions and temptation itself. Can’t have wrath without anger. Can’t have lust without attraction. Can’t have sloth without fear. Can’t have grief without death. If we were all bodyless ghosts incapable of death, why would we care about murder? Because in a ghosts perspective murder does not exist and if you never had a material body at all it would be an unfathomable question. Emotional cruelty hurts because it foreshadows physical harm and signals reduced safety. If you are someone who believes the soul is like a software then the body is the hardware. The body and brain can break the same way your computer can break and some damages cannot be repaired in a single lifetime and if your body is how you move in life then the software behind the wheel is limited in the directions it can go. The offender is both an agent and victim of their own brokenness. Judge the bodies who cause harm all you want but God is the one who is supposed to judge the soul. ---
**Author:** ![gospod\_janez](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/gospod_janez/32/876_2.png) [@gospod\_janez](https://briarfray.org/u/gospod_janez)\ **Post date:** [October 29, 2026, 12:39am UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/5 "2026-10-29T00:39:11Z")
Because “all\* have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23). None of us is worthy of going to Heaven, and we all need God’s mercy to achieve it. Also, when you “go” to Heaven (or Hell) you don’t stay as you were. Heaven is the contemplation of the essence of God for all eternity, and Hell is the complete separation from God for all eternity. Both are states of the soul, and in both those cases you are purified or stained completely, depending on your final destination, so it’s not like you could go to the New Earth (which after the resurrection I guess it would be an actual place) sinning and causing trouble. \*Except the BVM. ---
**Author:** ![Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/slinking_agony/32/842_2.png) [@Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/u/Slinking_Agony)\ **Post date:** [October 29, 2026, 2:05am UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/6 "2026-10-29T02:05:12Z")
Yes I am a furry, and proud! Why do you ask? Furthermore, it should be recalled that Furryism was forced on me. My artwork 14+ years ago are the same subjects as they are now, and I did not know what a furry was back then. But people eventually started labeling me a furry for my drawings, and although I said “Nuh-uh!”, the name stuck, so I suppose I am a furry. ---
**Author:** ![Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/slinking_agony/32/842_2.png) [@Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/u/Slinking_Agony)\ **Post date:** [October 29, 2026, 6:26am UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/7 "2026-10-29T06:26:35Z")
Maybe they were Catholic but I tend to not check because the Catholic/Protestant divide is silly to me. The 2,000-year-old jew babble book does not support the idea of purgatory or temporary hell. The rest of this makes sense, so thank you. If I was a bodyless ghost I would still not want to be around the ghost of whoever snuffed me out. (Assuming I don’t die from something natural) ---
**Author:** ![Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/slinking_agony/32/842_2.png) [@Slinking\_Agony](https://briarfray.org/u/Slinking_Agony)\ **Post date:** [October 29, 2026, 6:28am UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/8 "2026-10-29T06:28:36Z")
Alright. Is hell oblivion, then? If God is creation, then realistically, being seperated from him completely means that once ceases to exist. ---
**Author:** ![buddy\_vestigial](https://briarfray.org/user_avatar/briarfray.org/buddy_vestigial/32/871_2.png) [@buddy\_vestigial](https://briarfray.org/u/buddy_vestigial)\ **Post date:** [October 29, 2026, 7:10am UTC](https://briarfray.org/t/why-may-god-have-mercy-on-his-soul-is-a-dumb-thing-to-say-when-an-evil-person-dies/1171/9 "2026-10-29T07:10:46Z")
Many would present the exact same argument against you for being a sodomite and degenerate. There’s no telling how much damage you’ve done to other people and society for spreading such depraved perversions. If you are not physically brown, you are most assuredly spiritually brown. But this is why we have mercy and grace and repentance. Nobody is perfect.